Do Chinese Koreans (Chaoxianzu/Joseonjok) feel closer to Korea or China?
Kang-Lin Cheng, I'm just some guy
Answered Sep 9
Last time I was in China, my dad introduced me to several Korean-Chinese friends he had. Their views were generally this: culturally speaking, they identify as Koreans. However, from a nationality point of view, they see themselves as Chinese. They are proud of their Korean heritage (especially food, lol), but they have no interest in North or South Korea (as in the country). In fact, some of them even badmouth South Korea for not treating Korean Chinese immigrants well.
One Chaoxianzu lady did tell me, though, that when China was very poor (Cultural Revolution, Great Leap Forward eras), many Korean Chinese disliked Han Chinese and wanted nothing to do with them. However, no matter how bad ethnic tensions were, no one ever thought of rejoining Korea or demanding independence
Hyunwoo Kim, politics and ethics DPhil(PhD) at Oxford University
Updated Dec 6
I’m Chinese Korean and Choi Wonseok’s answer is really a curiosity for me. In terms of the nationality, yes, most of the Chinese Koreans, including myself, recognise the fact that we hold the PRC passport, and therefore we’re Chinese the same way Korean Americans are, in terms of the nationality, Americans.
The views of Chinese Koreans, however, differ largely in terms of their historical, cultural, and even political, identities. For instance, many think that we’re Korean in terms of our cultural roots while some claim that Chinese Korean culture has been so embedded in the Chinese context over the decades that we’re a branch of Chinese cultural diversity. Political identity should be seen different from a legal status. While we hold the PRC passport and are legally seen as Chinese nationalities, our attitudes towards Korea and two Koreas vary a lot depending on each individual’s own experience.
It’s true that many Chosunzok in South Korea refer to themselves as Chinese, but this is not due to their quite mysterious intimacy with China that comes from nowhere, but largely because of the fact that the South Koreans have never ceased to treat them with prejudice and discrimination, which pushes them off towards the Chinese side. One of the examples is shown in Choi Wonseok’s answer, which refers to the high crime rates of Chinese Koreans as justifying the stereotypes held by the South Koreans. The fact, however, is that Chosunzok only comes six or seventh in terms of overall crime rates and the crime rate per capita is significantly lower than Mongolians and Americans given the latter’s tiny population in South Korea. Here is a link that shows the prejudice. http://m.skyedaily.com/news_view.... Some old generation Chosunzok identify themselves as Chosunsaram, the people of the Korean peninsula, and not as belonging into either the North or South.
It should be recognised that many Chosunzok came to South Korea mainly looking for job opportunities to improve their lives. Ethnic minorities overall live in the periphery of China and are not well cared for by the central government. Many Chinese Koreans choose to come to South Korea where people are well-paid and send the money back to their family members in China. Most of the Chinese Koreans that you encounter in South Korea are economic migrants looking for a decent life. They often lack proper education and work very hard in manual labour industries that South Koreans see as dirty and better avoided. It’s no wonder that South Koreans tend to think that Chosunzok, as Choi Wonseok puts it, have “a large hand in providing this image of China as ‘rough’ or ‘uncultured’”. To the South Koreans Chosunzok appear to be ‘rough and uneducated’ because only the rough and uneducated choose to go to South Korea.
应该认识到，很多朝鲜族人去韩国主要是为了找工作改善自己的生活。 主要生活在中国外缘，并没有得到中央政府的多少照顾。很多中国朝鲜族人选择前往工资高的韩国，将钱寄给在中国的家人。很多你在韩国遇到的中国朝鲜族人都是为了过上好生活的经济移民者。他们往往缺少教育，从事体力行业，韩国人将这些工作视为肮脏的、唯恐避之不及的。正如Choi Wonseok指出的那样，所以韩国人认为朝鲜族人，“给人留下了中国人没教养、粗鲁的印象”。对韩国人而言，朝鲜族人看起来就是“粗鲁、没受过教育的”，因为只有粗鲁和没受过教育的人才去韩国。
What is less well-known is the fact that educated Chinese Koreans, which are no small proportion, proceed to do well in top universities in China, succeed in getting well-paid jobs in big cities such as Beijing and Shanghai and prosper in Chinese society. They have no reason to abandon all they achieved in China and adapt themselves to a new society where discrimination is rampant. Some of them, including myself, choose Japan, America or Europe for better education. Only those less competent go to South Korea for higher education because they can neither survive the Chinese educational system nor make their way forward to countries where the quality of higher education is better than in South Korea. In fact, the Chinese Koreans have the highest per capita rate of having college education amongst Chinese ethnic groups including the Han Chinese, and Chosunzok are reputed in China for great educational records.
It should also be noted that other answers that just treat Chosunzok as Chinese are too simplistic. Some may have strong feelings of ties with China but many just do not. For most Chinese Koreans, the Chinese nationality is just a legal status and Korea is an ambiguous entity that often makes nostalgic appeals to historical and cultural heritage. Most of us are just too busy to think about grand historical or nationalistic rhetorics—we’re just common people busy making life better for our family and ourselves.